Key points
- Semrush's study of 50,000 brands in ChatGPT found 53.7% of analyzed categories lacked any brand that showed up in most of five related prompts.
- Brands that surfaced in just one of a category's five sample prompts tied to lower mention share; the penalty vanished at three.
- Branded search volume was the only domain-level metric that consistently matched topic leadership, and the advantage was modest.
- Semrush recommends a scorecard of five to 10 Google keywords and five to 10 AI prompts per priority topic.
Why it matters for marketers: Topic-level visibility across many related prompts, not page count or a single ranking, is the measure to build around when buyers move between Google and AI tools.
Semrush has published a guide to topical authority that reframes the concept for a world where buyers move between Google, ChatGPT and communities like Reddit. It defines the term as the strength of a brand's link to a subject compared with competitors, built from its own site and from outside mentions.
The guide leans on Semrush's own research. In its 50,000-brand ChatGPT study, related prompts often returned entirely different brand names, and in more than half of the categories analyzed, no brand was a consistent presence across most of a five-prompt set. That suggests room for newcomers. Semrush also says publishing more pages does not help on its own, and overlapping pages can compete with each other.
For marketers, the takeaway is that a single keyword ranking or one tracked prompt can mislead. The guide says Google's AI features follow existing SEO practices, but query fan-out means one answer can draw on several searches. Authority Score and traffic did not reliably identify topic leaders either, so site-wide strength is not a substitute for topic-level checks.
On next steps, Semrush advises picking a few topics tied to the buyer journey and expertise, then checking which sources feed AI answers on each. It suggests building a scorecard of five to 10 Google keywords and five to 10 AI prompts per topic and comparing every competitor against the same set. Teams should also look at third-party publishers and competitor pages that shape how AI describes their brand.
Sources
This brief is our own summary. Read the full reporting at the source.