Key points
- OpenAI added cost-target bidding (Target CPA and Target CPC) to ChatGPT Ads; OpenAI said by Aug. 31 the ads product hit a $1 billion annualized run rate.
- A working paper covering 102 sites found ChatGPT ad visits earned about one-third the revenue of paid search visits in U.S. traffic: $0.89 versus $2.45 per session.
- The $0.52 versus $3.40 return per ad dollar mixes measured revenue with click prices from one ChatGPT account and 16 search accounts, so it is not a measured result.
- Agency tests are mixed: StubGroup found cheaper ChatGPT leads, Workshop Digital got zero qualified leads, and none show final customer or sales outcomes.
Why it matters for marketers: Budget shifts from Google to ChatGPT Ads should rest on your own spend and attributed revenue under matched settings, not on a per-dollar headline built from other advertisers' click prices.
OpenAI recently added cost-target bidding to ChatGPT Ads, which launched in February. The company said its ads product reached a $1 billion annualized run rate by Aug. 31. Search Engine Journal reviewed the available evidence on whether those ads now compete with Google Search Ads for budget.
The strongest dataset is a working paper using 102 websites with revenue tracking. In U.S. traffic, paid search produced $2.45 per session versus $0.89 for ChatGPT ad sessions, and 84 of 87 advertisers using both channels earned less per session from ChatGPT. The authors call the work descriptive, not causal. A widely cited $0.52 versus $3.40 return per ad dollar is not a measured figure. It relies on one ChatGPT account's click price and the median from 16 search accounts. OpenAI said the study covers an earlier period and extrapolates from a small sample.
Agency tests point in different directions. StubGroup saw lower cost per lead on ChatGPT, but Google leads appear to convert to customers more often so far. Workshop Digital got no qualified leads from ChatGPT. Brafton described the ads as "priced like search, but seem to behave like paid social." Neither company's revenue shows money actually moving between platforms.
For marketers, the practical step is a like-for-like test: the same period, the same attribution settings and the same definition of a qualified lead. Ads Manager can count view-through conversions and clicks differ from analytics sessions, so document those settings. Report session counts next to revenue, since a zero means little on a small test. The new Target CPA and Target CPC options were not in the paper's data window, so results may shift.
Sources
This brief is our own summary. Read the full reporting at the source.
